Yes, we’ve finally done it - Spectacu.la is now 100% GPL. All our themes are now available for free download.
Caribou Withdrawn - Temporarily
We’ve had to withdraw the Caribou News Theme for the time being, as it’s got elements that aren’t able to be released under the GPL license. Rather than wait (as we had been doing) we’ve decided to say sod it and simply withdraw it for the moment. When it does come out in GPL form it will, we feel, be the most powerful WordPress theme available with this license.
Why?
We had to get with the community, basically. Our plan had always been pragmatic - write a theme and later release it as GPL. That way we would be able to satisfy our commercial aims along with our community aims. But there’s a considerable amount of controversy over the detail of the GPL and in this case the view of the WordPress community didn’t agree with ours.
Now, you have a few choices when your views don’t align with your community - align with the community, change the community view, or fight your ground. Well, as far as we’re concerned life is too short to fight the community or to try and change it… so that left one choice. Well OK, two choices - we could have given up and shut up shop, but we’ve decided to continue with Spectacu.la for the moment.
There Are Downsides
We’re not at all sure if this way of running a club is a winning solution. Ultimately, we only offer our own themes - there’s nothing to stop a rival offering our themes (and others!) and undercutting us whilst offering the same level of forum support. They won’t have the cost of making themes, just of support. For sure, the community may do the honourable thing and avoid them, but I believe about 80% of the people out there aren’t really active members of the WordPress community. They don’t really care where they source their themes, and they’re not going to contribute.
We saw that when Brian Gardner withdrew his free downloads from Revolution Too that there must have been a problem with his model. We don’t know if it was costs, or hassle, or what, but he decided to give the free downloads up. Quietly he was dropped from WordPress.org, and that was the end of it. But he had, somehow, managed to stir up the whole wasps nest of debate on the GPL and when he first made the GPL announcement other clubs that were non-GPL were cast out.
A Promise
We will never ever withdraw our themes from free download. If the bandwidth gets a bit much then they’ll be available in the WordPress.org repository soon anyway (generously hosted by Automattic, I believe) and that will be fine for us. In fact, that’s what we want - we want it to be as easy as possible for you to install our themes on WordPress 2.8 when the auto-installation features come out. This is important and useful.
Memberships to the themes club are currently unavailable - watch the site for an announcement once the new payments gateway is tested (Paypal was too expensive and too clunky for us) and you’ll soon be able to join the forums once more.
Past members who supported us in the early days will be given a year’s free membership.